• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

SI Parent

Solutions For Parenting In Staten Island

Get Weekly Activities
Emailed To You
Subscribe
  • Connect With SI Parent:
  • Things To Do
  • Directories
    • After School
    • Birthday Parties
    • Summer Camps
    • Pre-School & Daycare
    • Health and Wellness
    • Special Needs
    • Home Improvement
  • Articles
    • Featured Articles
    • Positive Parenting
    • Stuff To Do
    • Coronavirus
    • Babies and Pregnancy
    • Special Needs Articles
    • Recipes and Food
    • Health and Safety
    • School, Camp and Education
    • Richmond University Medical Center
  • Subscribe
    • Newsletter
    • Birthday Club
  • Advertise With Us
  • SI Parent Guides
Home / Articles / Positive Parenting / 9 Ideas: What to Do with Your Kids’ Old Toys

9 Ideas: What to Do with Your Kids’ Old Toys

October 3, 2023 By Barbara Russo

9 Ideas: What to Do with Your Kids’ Old Toys
Photo credit: yavdat/Getty Images

What to Do with Your Kids’ Old Toys

The arrival of fall means the holiday season is around the corner! It’ll soon be time to check off the items on your kids’ wishlists. But in the meantime, you might be wondering, “How will we have room for all these new toys?” Well don’t fret, because we put together a list of what to do with your kids’ old toys that they outgrew or just don’t play with anymore. From recycling programs to charitable donations, these suggestions will help ensure that the toys that brought your little ones so much joy will continue to do so for others.  

What to Do with Your Kids’ Old Toys

Mattel PlayBack Program

This company has so many popular toys, including the famous Barbie! Its PlayBack program allows you to ship your kids’ Mattel toys–specifically Barbie, Fisher-Price, Matchbox and MEGA toys–back to the company, where they are then recycled and reused as contents in new products. (We know, it sounds sad, but it actually helps keep toys out of landfills.) To participate, go to the website and fill out a short form to receive a free prepaid shipping label. Package your toys, and then send ‘em on out. 

Hasbro Toy Recycling

Mr. Potato Head. My Little Pony. Playskool. These are just a few popular Hasbro brands that you can send back as part of the company’s Toy Recycling program, which is a partnership with recycling company, TerraCycle. Once you send back your toys, the company recycles them into new materials and products, including play spaces, flower pots and park benches. 

Spin Master Free Recycling Program

Recycling is a popular suggestion on what to do with your kids’ old toys. Spin Master toys, which include PAW Patrol and Rubik’s Cube brands, can be recycled through the company’s free recycling program. The company, like Hasbro, does its toy recycling program in partnership with TerraCycle. Once you send back your Spin Master toys (you can see a full list of toys on its website), they’re cleaned and melted into hard plastic that can be remolded to make new recycled products, such as park benches and picnic tables, instead of ending up in a landfill. 

Stuffed Animal Box

Your kids aren’t playing with their stuffed animals anymore, but it might seem horrifying to think of these beloved plush companions winding up in the trash. Well there’s good news: They don’t have to! You can purchase a TerraCycle Zero Waste Box (prices start at $110), fill it with your stuffed animals and send them out. The toys are then sorted and processed into raw materials that are used to make new products.

LEGO Replay 

If your kids are ready to move on from their LEGOs, you can pass forward these much-loved toy bricks to kids in need. Just box up your bricks, print out a label and ship them out. Kids will get a box filled with a variety of bricks and elements to play with, as well as a cool activity booklet with some fun building activities to try out!   

What to do with Your Kids’ Old Toys: Giving Back

Charities

If you’re looking for more answers on what to do with your kids’ old toys, consider donating them to charities! Many charities such as Goodwill and The Salvation Army will resell your donated items and use the money to support their causes. If you have a new, unwrapped toy that you’d like to give, Toys for Tots is another option. It’s run by the U.S. Marine Corps Reserve, and their mission is to collect new, unwrapped toys and distribute them to less fortunate children at Christmas.

Homes and Shelters

That adorable teddy bear and plush bunny, and those beautiful dolls in your child’s old toy chest will almost certainly bring joy to children going through a difficult time. Consider calling local children’s and women’s shelters to see if they’re accepting toys, and if so, how you can go about donating. 

Churches, Synagogues and other Religious Organizations

Consider contacting these organizations to see if they know of any families in need who can use toys. 

Stuffed Animals for Emergencies (SAFE)

This wonderful organization provides comfort for children in traumatic or emergency situations through donations of stuffed animals, blankets, books, children’s clothes and baby items. This beautiful mission gives you the opportunity to donate these beloved items so that they can be used to comfort kids who need them, and not thrown away.  

Ways to recycle other items

Now that you have a few tips on what to do with your kids’ old toys, here are a few bonus ideas for recycling other household items, too:

Umbrellas. Broken or unwanted umbrellas can be upcycled into tote bags.  The metal spokes can be recycled at a scrap metal facility.

Pet food bags. Dry pet food bags, once empty, can be used as trash bags or upcycled into tote bags. 

Paint. Through the PaintCare program, many stores accept unwanted paint for paint recycling. Check out paintcare.org for a store locator and instructions on how to make your donation. 

 


Wanna read more stuff like this? Get our newsletters packed with ideas, events, and information for parents in Staten Island.

Filed Under: Positive Parenting, Featured Articles

Featured Events

Post an Event

This summer, get ready for a celebration
Today, 10 am

LEGO® Summer of Play Event at LEGOLAND Discovery Center New Jersey
LEGOLAND® Discovery Center New Jersey

Splash into summer with an adventure alo
Today, 10 am

The Great Pirates & Mermaids Adventure
SEALIFE New Jersey at American Dream

Join our ShopRite Kidz Cook team at the
Today, noon

ShopRite Kidz Cook: Berry Parfaits
Staten Island Children’s Museum

Join staff from the Dongan Hills Library
Today, 3 pm

Summer Adventure: Afrofuturist Gadget Building
Dongan Hills Library

This event is in person Introduction to
Today, 3:15 pm

Balloon Bending Bonanza!
Huguenot Park Library

Free movies @ Dongan Hills Library! Ever
Tomorrow, 10:30 am

Summer Movies @ Dongan Hills Library
Children’s room

View All Events…

Primary Sidebar

View Local Activities for Kids
  • Overcoming the Dangers of the Summer Sun: Melanoma and Skin Health
  • Here’s Where to Adopt a Pet in Staten Island
  • Teachers’ Top Needs for 2019
  • Fall Bucket List for Staten Island Families 2023
  • 31 Places to Take Photos with Santa In New York Area

Staten Island Parent

Staten Island Parent helps parents make better decisions. We have the latest activities and local events that matter to you. Plus many informative articles and important directories including schools, afterschool programs, camps, special needs, birthday parties, health and wellness. Our contests and clubs are fun for the whole family!

    • Browse Past Issues
    • Get Activities & School Info

Footer

si parent logo
Staten Island Parent
One MetroTech Center 3rd Floor
Brooklyn, NY 11201
(646) 559–9100

Important Links

  • Subscribe
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Browse Past Issues
  • Where to Find The Magazine
  • Write For Staten Island Parent
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap

Get Weekly Activities Emailed To You

Subscribe

Copyright © 1989-2025 Staten Island Parent Magazine, All Rights Reserved