What’s great about shopping at holiday fairs in Staten Island this holiday season? You can find beautiful, unique gifts for family and friends, all while supporting local business at a time when they need it most. Many schools, churches, and other organizations are hosting holiday fairs, auctions, and other shopping events starting as early as this month, and leading deep into the holiday season. Many of them also raise funds for important causes while celebrating the joys of the holiday season. Think of these 2021 Staten Island holiday fairs as one-stop shopping for all of your Christmas, Hanukkah, or festive shopping needs!
Below you will find a list of holiday fairs in Staten Island this year. It’s a good idea to call or check the venue’s website in advance for COVID precautions that may be in place and to confirm the fair is still happening as planned.
After your shopping is done (or even before!), browse our things-to-do calendar, which is packed with fun and festive holiday events the whole family will enjoy this season, or head to a farm in New Jersey to cut your own Christmas tree!
October Holiday Fairs in Staten Island
1. Great Kills Moravian Church Christmas Fair
62 Hillside Terrace
718-317-7788
Facebook
When: Saturday, Oct. 30, 10am-3pm
Shop Christmas craft items and give back to your community at this Staten Island holiday fair. The church is collecting new hats, mittens and gloves to be given to those in need this winter.
November Holiday Fairs in Staten Island
1. Reformed Protestant Dutch Church Community Christmas Holiday Fair
54 Port Richmond Ave.
717-442-7393
Facebook
When: Sunday, Nov. 7, 1-5pm
Visit this holiday fair for more than shopping. Browse handmade gifts including jewelry, embroidery, and art, and stay for a guided tour of the landmark site. Food and drinks available.
2. The Church of St. Andrew Holiday Fair
40 Old Mill Road
718-351-0900
Facebook • Instagram
When: Nov. 12-13, Friday-Saturday, 11am-5pm
This holiday fair in Staten Island offers unique gifts and home-made holiday items. The fair also includes luncheons, a parish dinner, and a visit from Santa.
View this post on Instagram
3. John A. Noble Art Auction
1000 Richmond Terrace
718-447-6490
Facebook • Instagram
When: Saturday, Nov. 13; 6:30pm
Work in the auction is donated by artists and art collectors. It is the museum’s premier fundraising event with proceeds supporting exhibitions and programs for students and the broader public. Tickets are $90.
4. Staten Island Heart Society Friendsgiving Limited Share Lottery
3055 Richmond Rd.
718-351-3115
Facebook • Instagram
When: Thursday, Nov. 18
Tickets are $100 with prizes up to $10,000. Only 300 tickets will be sold. More details on how to participate are available on the website.
5. Staten Island Council for Animal Welfare Holiday Fair
Immanuel Union Church, 693 Jewett Ave.
718-448-1584
Facebook • Instagram
When: Saturday, Nov. 20, 10am-4pm
Don’t forget about our furry, finned, and feathered friends this holiday season! Browse holiday gifts and tons of raffle baskets, where all proceeds benefit the Staten Island Council for Animal Welfare.
6. St. Alban’s Episcopal Church Holiday Fair
76 St. Alban’s Place
718-984-7756
When: Saturday, Nov. 6, 10am-6pm
Lots of vendors set up shop at this annual holiday fair on Staten Island. Browse holiday gifts including books, attic treasures, Christmas items, toys, games, and more.
7. Monsignor Farrell High School Christmas Fair
2900 Amboy Road
718-987-2900
Facebook • Instagram
When: Sunday, Nov. 7, 9:30am
Shop craft vendors and enjoy raffles and food trucks.
8. St. John’s Lutheran Church’s Christmas Fair
216 Jewett Ave.
718-761-1600
When: Saturday, Nov. 20, 9am-3pm
Browse a selection of handmade ornaments and baked goods at this Staten Island holiday fair.
9. Christ Lutheran Church Christmas Fair
121 Cleveland Ave.
718-984-6595
Facebook
When: Saturday, Nov. 20, 9am-3pm
Vendors, face painting, raffles and a bake sale are on-site at this holiday fair.
10. Team Real Holiday Vendor Fair
2298 Arthur Kill Road
347-979-4955
Facebook • Instagram
When: Saturday, Nov. 27, 4-8pm
Head to this Staten Island gym for more than a good workout. This year the gym will host a holiday fair featuring a variety of items for sale by local vendors, including home décor, art, clothing, and more.
11. PS 37 Holiday Vendor Extravaganza
15 Fairfield St.
718-984-9800
WHEN: Saturday, Nov. 13, 9am-4pm; rain date: Nov. 14
Enjoy browsing various vendors and food trucks.
December Holiday Fairs in Staten Island
1. National Lighthouse Museum Holiday Golf Outing
South Shore Golf Course, 200 Huguenot Ave.
718-390-0040
Facebook • Instagram
When: Friday, Dec. 3, 12:30pm
The museum will host its annual golf outing with all you can eat and drink, raffles, and more.
2. EJ Michael’s Holiday Sip & Shop
137 Barnard Ave.
Facebook • Instagram
When: Saturday, Dec. 4, 6-10pm
This free and fun evening shopping event on Staten Island will host a variety of local and national vendors including Mary Kay, Tupperware, Petals on Page, Lil Sweet Treats, and more. There will also be a cash bar and food available for purchase.
View this post on Instagram
3. Noble Maritime Collection Culture Shop
1000 Richmond Terrace
718 447-6490
Facebook • Instagram
When: Saturday, Dec. 4, 11am-4pm
Head to the Noble Maritime Collection’s annual Culture Shop where you can browse a variety of hand-made items for sale from local artists and craftspeople including clocks, pottery, jewelry, soaps, and more.
4. Art Lab Holiday Fair
1000 Richmond Terrace
718-447-8667
Facebook • Instagram
When: Saturday, Dec. 4; hours to be announced
This year’s fair will be limited. Check the website for updates.
5. Staten Island Mall Sensory Friendly Holiday Magic
2655 Richmond Ave.
718-761-6666
Facebook • Instagram
When: Sundays, Dec. 5 and 12, 9:30-10:30am
In partnership with Autism Speaks, Sensory Friendly Santa Experience is for children with autism to visit with Santa in a welcoming, sensory-friendly environment.
6. Christmas Xtravaganza
NYCArtsCypher, 12 Broad St.
718-981-8510
Facebook • Instagram
When: Dec. 11-12, Saturday-Sunday, 1-6pm
Browse vendors, and enjoy music, raffles and food. Plus, Santa will be there to visit with kids. Bring a toy to be donated to Toys for Tots. ($5 suggested entry)
7. Sensory Santa Day at Empire Outlets
55 Richmond Terrace
Facebook • Instagram
When: Sunday, Dec. 12, 10-11am
Autism Speaks presents Sensory Santa day. Sensory Santa day is an opportunity for children with autism and/or sensory processing disorders to visit Santa in a quiet, welcoming, sensory-friendly environment. Reservations required.
8. Eger Lutheran Homes and Services Scandinavian Holiday Fair
140 Meisner Ave.
718-979-1800
When: To be announced
Check the website for complete details to be announced.
9. Christmas Fair
Crafty Kids and St. Paul’s United Methodist Church
7558 Amboy Rd.
Facebook
WHEN: Friday, Dec. 10, 4:30-8:30pm
Vendors, baked goods, raffles, crafts.
10. Santa’s Workshop at Holy Child Preschool
4747 Amboy Rd.
718-356-5159
Facebook • Instagram
WHEN: Saturday, Dec. 11, 10am-4pm
Crafts, photos with Santa, raffles and vendors.
Wanna learn about more awesome family activities? Get our newsletters packed with ideas, events, and information for parents in Staten Island.
