Apple cider donuts on Staten Island and Nearby in New Jersey
The taste of fall is in the air. But we’re not talking about the ever-popular pumpkin spice flavor; we’re talking about apple cider donuts! Here’s where you can get apple cider donuts on Staten Island and nearby in New Jersey. Nothing says fall like pumpkin picking, navigating through a corn maze and…enjoying a sweet, fresh apple cider donut! Get one as a treat for yourself, or bring home a dozen for the family to enjoy. Whatever you decide, apple cider donuts are a great way to ring in seasonal fall fun!
Apple Cider Donuts on Staten Island
Annadale Bakery
821 Annadale Road
929-284-3400
Hours: Call for information.
Price: $3 per donut
This quaint Italian bakery is nestled in the heart of Annadale town. Stop by to get some apple cider donuts that have a delicious, signature taste of fall. You’ll first notice the donut’s eye-catching light-brown color. It also has a unique texture that is fresh and sweet with small hits of apple—a very classic apple cider donut taste!
Holtermann’s Bakery
405 Arthur Kill Road
718-984-7095
Hours: Sunday-Monday, 7:30am-4:30pm; Tuesday-Saturday, 7:30am-6pm
Price: $1.35 per donut
Holtermann’s has been a mainstay on Staten Island since 1878, so it’s safe to say the bakers here know a thing or two about making delicious donuts. Upon entering the shop, you’ll be embraced by a sweet aroma of baked goods, but stay focused! Your goal is the apple cider donuts! This seasonal delight sells out fast, so it’s best to get there as early in the day as possible to avoid disappointment.
Country Donuts
4357 Amboy Road
718-356-0884
3235 Richmond Ave.
718-967-7111
Hours: Monday-Saturday, 5am-10pm; Sunday, 5am-7pm
Price: $1.69 per donut
Stop by one of these Country Donuts locations to get apple cider donuts on Staten Island. You can get a multi-pack of apple cider donuts, or order them individually.
Trader Joe’s
2385 Richmond Ave.
718-370-1085
Hours: Daily, 8am-9pm
Price: $4.49 for a box of six
Trader Joe’s might be an unexpected place to find apple cider donuts on Staten Island, but they have them, and they’re delicious! Pick up a box for the family, but be sure to save one for yourself. They’re great with coffee in the morning (or anytime)!
Old School Baker with a Twist
Place your order on Facebook at Old School Baker with a Twist or Instagram @Wholeheartedlyhealthyliving
Price: $30 per dozen donuts
Business owner Alessandra Ambio makes a variety of baked goods. If you like cakey, moist and dense donuts with a crumbly cinnamon-sugar coating, these are for you! You’ll see some great photos of the treats on Ambio’s Instagram page.
Apple Cider Donuts in New Jersey
There’s a list of places to get apple cider donuts on Staten Island, but don’t overlook some local farms and markets in New Jersey, too. The places listed here are all located less than an hour’s drive from Staten Island, so you won’t have to travel too far to get your hands on this seasonal treat.
Battleview Orchards
91 Wemrock Road, Freehold
732-462-0756
Hours: 9am-6pm (until 5pm Jan.-April) every day except Tuesday
Price: Call for information.
Apple cider donuts are made fresh daily all year. You can also pick up some apple cider, which is available mid-Septmeber through mid-May. While you’re there, consider going pumpkin picking on the farm, too!
Delicious Orchards
Route 34 South, Colts Neck
732-462-1989
Hours: 9:30am-6pm every day except Monday
Price: Call for information.
The market has apple cider donuts and other treats.
Von Thun’s Country Farm Market
519 Ridge Road, Monmouth Junction
732-329-8656
Hours: Open daily, mid-May through mid-November; Monday-Friday, 10am-5pm; Saturday-Sunday, 9am-5pm
Price: Call for information.
The market has homemade apple cider donuts, apple cider, fresh baked pies and more.
Ort Farms
25 Bartley Road, Long Valley
908-876-3351
Hours: Monday-Saturday, 9am-7pm; Sunday, 9am-6pm
Price: Call for information.
These donuts are available plain, with cinnamon or with confectioners sugar and sold by the dozen or half dozen.
Wanna read more stuff like this? Get our newsletters packed with ideas, events, and information for parents in Staten Island.
